Young Dean Winchester

Andrea Barr

Cuthbert Sinclair, Gym Club Victim

Samuel Colt

Gilda

Walt, Bartender

'Dean', Damien

Sari

Meredith McDonell

College Professor

Assistant Director, Pauly

Samandriel, Alfie, Matt Pike

Claire Becker

Ishim, Lee Chambers

Lucifer, President Jefferson Rooney

Sergeant 'Sarge' Joe Phillips

Gerald, Pete Hensley

Kevin Tran

Demon Trucker

Freeman Daggett, Moloch, Scarecrow, The Golem

Lily Sunder

Agent Nick Monroe

Silvia Pearlman, Witch #1

Adam Milligan, Michael

Leprechaun, Wayne Whittaker Jr.

Seth